Partial victory for Next in equal pay appeal, but store staff’s legal team also claim a win

Published
September 7, 2026
Next has said it won its appeal against a landmark UK ruling on equal pay in British retail, which the homewares and clothing retail giant had claimed would threaten the viability of many of its stores. But the other side also claimed a partial victory and will appeal.

The Employment Appeal Tribunal ruled Next could legally pay warehouse workers higher wages than shop staff because it cost more to recruit and retain them, according to the judgement.
Two years ago, a landmark judgement for equal pay in the private sector came when the employment tribunal said Next’s shop-floor staff — who were mostly women paid lower hourly rates — were at a particular disadvantage compared with men working in warehouses.
But Next had said warehouse worker pay rates were higher than those of retail workers across the market so it had to compete as it tried to recruit and retain them, with the same pressures not applying to the workforce in its stores.
UK law says work judged to be of equal value should get equal pay whether it’s done by a man or a woman, unless there’s a demonstrable non-discriminatory reason for doing otherwise.
Next said Monday that if the tribunal rejected its appeal, many of its roughly 500 stores would be too expensive to staff. And it pointed out in its statement that there was no finding of direct sex discrimination.
But it wasn’t a complete victory for the company as the judge rejected some aspects of Next’s appeal. The press office of law firm Leigh Day also issued a statement saying “thousands of current and former Next store workers have held on to their landmark equal pay victory in a mixed ruling”.
It said the Employment Appeal Tribunal rejected Next’s challenge to the Tribunal’s findings that it had failed to justify lower rates of night-time pay, overtime pay and the failure to provide paid rest breaks to store workers.
It “also failed to persuade the Employment Appeal Tribunal that lower Sunday premium payments to store workers were justified. The Appeal Tribunal held that the issue remains to be determined and should return to the Employment Tribunal”.
Elizabeth George, partner at Leigh Day representing the claimants, said: “I am pleased that the Employment Appeal Tribunal rejected Next’s arguments that its pay practices do not disadvantage women… [and] upheld the findings on night-time premiums, overtime premiums and paid rest breaks.
“The Appeal Tribunal’s conclusion on basic pay is disappointing. If an employer need only show it pays the market rates to justify pay discrimination, the very market conditions that give rise to the discrimination then become the legal justification.
“While the store staff and their legal team welcome many aspects of this appeal judgment, we respectfully disagree with this approach to justification. We remain confident in our clients’ position and intend to appeal.”
Written with Bloomberg
Copyright © 2026 FashionNetwork.com All rights reserved.